Honestly? I’ve gone through more Adirondack chairs than I care to admit. Some cracked after one winter. Others faded into sad, chalky ghosts by July. But Polywood and Lifetime? They stick around. Like that one friend who shows up whether it’s a barbecue or a blizzard.
Polywood.
God, these things feel indestructible. Made from this dense recycled plastic—HDPE, yeah—but it doesn’t feel cheap. More like… solid. Heavy. The Modern Adirondack? Sleek lines. Looks expensive parked on a deck. And it performs. Left mine buried under three feet of wet Michigan snow last February. Dug it out in spring. Not a scratch. Not even a weird creak. Sun-bleached? Nope. Still that rich teak color. Comfort’s legit too—that contoured back hugs your spine just right. But wow, the price tag makes you gulp. You’re paying for that bulletproof vibe. Worth it? If you hate replacing stuff, absolutely. If your budget’s tight… maybe not.
Then there’s Lifetime.
The practical cousin. No frills, no fancy angles—just a classic, sturdy Adirondack shape. That wide armrest? Perfect for balancing a cold beer. They’ve got colors—sunny yellow, deep forest green—that Polywood can’t touch. And the cost? Way kinder to your wallet. I bought two for the price of one Polywood. Assembly though… ugh. Took me 45 minutes sweating in the driveway, cross-referencing instructions that looked like they were photocopied in 1998. One screw hole was slightly off. Had to muscle it. Not fun. But once built? Rock solid. Rain. Heatwaves. Kids jumping on ’em. They just… endure. They won’t win design awards, but they get the job done.
So which one?
If you want your yard to look like a West Elm catalog—sharp, modern, “I spent serious cash here”—Polywood’s your fix. That HDPE won’t warp or splinter like wood. Ever. It’s an heirloom chair. But yeah, you’ll feel that heirloom price.
Lifetime? For most folks? Probably the smarter buy. Especially if you’ve got kids, dogs, or just hate fussing over patio furniture. It’s the reliable pickup truck of Adirondacks. Unsexy but unbreakable. That assembly hassle? Annoying, sure. But you do it once. Then forget it. For years.
Look—I own both. Polywood on my front porch where guests see it. Lifetime around the firepit where life actually happens. Spilled marshmallow syrup? Hose it off. Doesn’t care. Polywood’s beautiful, don’t get me wrong. But sometimes… you just need a chair that doesn’t make you nervous when someone plops down with a dripping popsicle. Lifetime gets that. It’s not glamorous. It just works.
Honestly? If money was no object, I’d go Polywood everywhere. But money is an object. So… I compromise. Which feels kinda human, right?
| Feature | Polywood Adirondack Chair | Lifetime Adirondack Chair |
|---|---|---|
| Design/Style | Clean lines, minimalist, contemporary style | Traditional Adirondack slat design with subtle curves |
| Sleek, modern aesthetic | Rustic, timeless charm reminiscent of early 20th century originals | |
| Materials | HDPE (high-density polyethylene) recycled plastic lumber | Polystyrene plastic with UV inhibitors and simulated woodgrain |
| Solid synthetic wood alternative | Plastic/resin core with woodgrain surface texture | |
| Colors | Multiple options like black, white, teak, gray | Natural wood tones like weathered teak, cedar, mahogany |
| Contoured Seat | Ergonomic with lumbar support curve | Curved, contoured for ergonomic support |
| Seat Height | 12-14 inches (shorter for some taller folks) | 15+ inches (better for long legs) |
| Back Angle | 16-20 degree reclined pitch | Around 15 degree reclined angle |
| Weight Capacity | 400 lbs | 300-350 lbs |
| Weather Resistance | Impervious to moisture, UV, salt, insects | Polystyrene resists moisture, UV light. Not insect/rot proof |
| Expected Lifespan | 20+ years with proper care | 10-15 years with proper care |
| Maintenance | Only requires periodic cleaning with soap/water | Occasional cleaning. No need to restain/reseal |
| Stain resistant and easy to wipe clean | Some colorant transfer possible | |
| Assembly | Typically requires full assembly out of box | Often shipped pre-assembled |
| Product Weight | 35-45 lbs | 30-40 lbs |
| Eco-Friendliness | Made from recycled plastic materials | New plastic materials, not recycled |
| Price Range | $200 – $500+ | $150 – $300 |
After dumping nearly eight grand on Terra Outdoor Living furniture for my California backyard redo…
As a seasoned outdoor furniture connoisseur, I’ve had the privilege of exploring a myriad of…
As someone who’s spent a considerable amount of time exploring the world of outdoor furniture,…
As an outdoor furniture enthusiast, I’ve had the pleasure of experiencing a wide range of…
When selecting outdoor furniture, two popular choices often come to mind: Laguna wood and Polywood.…
Why Polywood and Serwall Are Constantly Compared If you’ve been searching for outdoor furniture that…